Let’s talk about money. A Robotic Knee Replacement typically costs ₹60,000 to ₹1,00,000 more than a traditional one. As a surgeon who has performed hundreds of both traditional (manual) and robotic surgeries, I am often asked: “Doctor, is it really worth the extra cost?”
The honest answer? It depends.
I am not a salesman. I am a doctor. If I believe you can get a 100% perfect result with traditional surgery, I will tell you. But there are specific cases where I will insist on the Robot.
The Decision Matrix: Which One Fits You?
Scenario A: The Traditional Candidate
- Anatomy: Standard, straightforward arthritis.
- Bone Quality: Good.
- Budget: Strict constraints.
- My Take: Traditional surgery, in experienced hands (like mine), is still a gold-standard procedure. I use high-precision manual jigs. You will walk, you will be pain-free, and you will save money.
Scenario B: The Robotic Candidate (The “Must-Haves”)
- Complex Anatomy: If you have had a fracture before, or severe deformity (bow-legs).
- Younger Age (Under 60): You need this knee to last 25+ years. The sub-millimeter alignment of the robot reduces wear and tear, potentially extending the implant’s life.
- Fast Recovery Needed: If you need to get back to work in Andheri or catch the train from Borivali within a few weeks. The robot causes less soft-tissue damage, allowing for a “Fast Track” recovery.
The “Rework” Math
Think of it this way: The cost of a revision surgery (redoing a failed knee) is huge—both financially and physically.
- Traditional: 90-95% accuracy.
- Robotic: 99.9% accuracy.
That extra 5% is your insurance policy against future problems.
Unsure which category you fit into? Come to my OPD. I will show you your X-Rays and give you an honest recommendation—no pressure.